5. A practical example is weather forecasting. UK Conservative Leadership: Climate Policy? Less houses will be made available for rent, causing excess demand for rental houses. What are the lessons for us from these failures? Corporate governance: Corporate governance plays an important role in risk management in the real estate industry. The company was not as adept at spotting, assessing and mitigating risks as it imagined. You are currently accessing Risk.net via your Enterprise account. Exposing individuals at various levels of management to the goals and objectives of the ERM program are not the same as promoting and embedding risk awareness. An "accumulation of cascading decisions," the weaknesses contributed to a significant failure. Target Corporation, the second-largest discount retailer in the United States, behind Walmart. Between 2015 and 2020 alone, global AML failures occurred consistently, including: 115 cases of failed customer due diligence. By clicking Accept, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Failure No. Recent history has seen some of the world's preeminent brands come under fire from the media, and even their most devoted followers. A failure to produce much value despite mounting time invested is a common management failure. The most frequent cause is human error. If a task fails, there are ways to reallocate resources and get back on track. Risk management in projects requires a holistic approach to be solved. It appears GM underestimated the probability of the risks associated with the faulty engineering, and failed to recalculate risks in a Bayesian fashion. Companies are registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09232733 & 04699701. No stakeholders backing and lack of ownership. Organization: US Military Project type : Development of a multirole fighter aircraft and associated systems Project name : F-35 Lightning II Date : Jan 2021 Cost : $1.7T Synopsis : When procuring defence systems one of the key strategic decisions needing to be . 10. The following entry is a record in the "Catalogue of Catastrophe" - a list of failed or troubled projects from around the world. Analyzing and providing recommendations for various supply chain functions and risk, this book includes risk associated during various states of procurement, logistics/transportation, and manufacturing, warehousing . Business Analysis. By making this choice she is risking that she will run out of gas in her car on the way to work. We also analyze the events by industry and time period to derive deeper insights into patterns of these failure events. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. If a tornado destroys a warehouse or an employee accidentally damages a computer server, the potential loss of the company assets forms an operational risk exposure. These processes typically create simplicity and order and can also become self-reinforcing and entrenched. GM is facing similar penalties. Summary We have discussed five common risk management failures: Poor governance and "tone at the organization" Reckless risk-taking Inability to implement effective ERM Nonexistent, ineffective or inefficient risk assessment Here are four benefits of risk management: 1. I continue to accept a limited number of consulting engagements. Despite the knowledge of hindsight, it is worth emphasising that none of the stakeholders involved in these examples would have stated at the time that risk management was unimportant for them. Unrealistic planning . The piece ended pessimistically, stating that It might be a while before GM can quantify its ERM programs impact. It seems this pessimism was unwarranted. Welcome to Risk.net's annual ranking of the top op risks for 2021, based on a survey of operational risk practitioners across the globe and in-depth interviews with respondents.. As in years past, there is no great secret to the methodology: Risk.net's editorial team gets in touch with 100 chief risk officers, heads of operational risk and senior practitioners at financial services firms . Courses. Ossified Management Process. Project leaders play a crucial role in ensuring that the risks that arise during the project are solved. 3 Projects that Failed Miserably 1. All rights reserved. Poor leadership skills. It evolved well and played an important role in the creation of. Crisis management examples are easy to find these days: We've seen Uber lose 200,000 users in the wake of #DeleteUber and United lose $800 million in . For example, assume that government increases the minimum employee salary by 100%. Project Management Institute; ProjectManagement.com; Disciplined Agile; Brightline Initiative; CEO Corner; Global Accreditation Center; PMI Educational Foundation Risk Edge is a leading Solution provider for Machine Learning & Risk Analytics, used by medium and large Energy & Commodity Trading Players. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". A woman watches a man kidnap a child. It does not store any personal data. Predicting Credit Defaults using Machine Learning. Please email [emailprotected] for more information. After all, something went wrong with our process in this instance, and terrible things happenedWe are conducting an intense review of our internal processes.. Insights - World's Biggest Risk Management Failures - Risk Edge Solutions About Us Risk Edge is a leading Solution provider for Machine Learning & Risk Analytics, used by medium and large Energy & Commodity Trading Players. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Poor financial estimates. The chapter will also provide some generic guidance that will help prepare us for the analysis in the remainder of this book. 82 cases of failed suspicious transaction monitoring. The International Law of War and Russias Special Military Operation, Opinion: The Attempted Assassination of Brett Kavanaugh and Far-Left Extremism. These generally relate to high-level risk management strategy, addressing organizational issues related to risk management, or risk measure analytics. We picked three accidents from the years 2018 and 2019 to create a better understanding of how this simple-to-hear factor . The United States War Against Russian Disinformation: Is the GEC Fit for Purpose? It is, unfortunately, the failures that make up the majority of case studies. The paper not only gives a brief about the models, so as to not give them a black-box feel but also shows how they can be tweaked in multiple ways using advanced Machine learning techniques to improve their accuracy! Intolerance of Failure The Indian agents who provided Custer with the information based their numbers on a guesstimate. Please try again later. If you are a Risk.net subscriber you are entitled to 20% off your Risk books purchases. Togetherness enables coworkers to work toward a common goal. Cloud Computing & Zoom the video calling app of choice! As eager customers waited, few PT Cruisers became available due to manufacturing constraints and poor production efforts. These cookies are necessary for the website to function and cannot be disabled in our systems. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. But the questions surrounding those failures are perhaps bigger than any single event. As a result, dealerships refunded many customer deposits. 1: Poor Governance and "Tone at the Top" Effective governance and tone at the top drive the transparency, openness and commitment to continuous improvement that is needed for risk management to function effectively. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Borders Group Inc. Once the second-largest book store chain in the United States, Borders Group Inc. (Borders) made a strategic error that played a role in the company's eventual bankruptcy. If you are an existing subscriber from Energy / Commodity company, you dont need to fill this form again, youll receive this paper in your registered email id ! 62 cases of poor compliance monitoring and oversight. Corporate goals not understood at lower levels of the organisation. Here are five examples of business communication gone wrong and how the companies involved responded. Chain Risk Management offers insider guidelines for managing the risk of supply chains gained from customer success and failures. A company and its officers were fined a total of 245,000 and ordered to pay costs of 75,500 at Crown Court in relation to the removal of asbestos. While these risk management anecdotes are unfortunate, they all could have been different by planning ahead and the use of a quality risk management plan in place. And, as mentioned in a previous blog, there are repercussions to doing business with the wrong suppliers, such as: Supply interruptions or discontinuities. 1: Poor Governance and "Tone at the Top" Effective governance and tone at the top drive the transparency, openness and commitment to continuous improvement that is needed for risk management to function effectively. They all practiced some form of risk management to keep abreast of developments, and what really matters is the underlying belief of how risk management would be practised. Give regular updates on the status of risk responses. Copyright Infopro Digital Limited. If you would like to place an order please email [emailprotected], An Introduction to Behavioural Risk Management, Value-at-Risk as the Dominant Risk Management Tool in the Financial Industry, The Role of Regulation in Risk Management, Advances in Behavioural Economics and Finance, Behavioural Risk Management in the Financial Markets, Behavioural Risk Management: Closing Thoughts, Appendix: Selective list of Behavioural Biases. Pareto ordering is used to guide corrective action and to help the project team. What Is Cost of Quality in Project Management? Read Blog. 2) It can cause a black market to develop. There are plenty of potential downsides to not getting a handle on your risk management: from damaging team morale and losing the respect of your customers to inhibiting your productivity and innovation. The communication and evaluation of existing internal risks in this case, faulty ignition switches did not take placefor 10years. It lost the battle for market share to JVC's VHS technology, but Sony didn't stop making Betamax tapes until 2016. Probably the biggest indicator of the likelihood of risk is whenever you hear the word "new", i.e. 1. GM can now quantify its impact; the ERM program could cost well over a billion dollars. Through the use of various case studies and real life challenges such as the year 2008 credit predicament, natural disasters, enormous outsourcing to the Chinese republic and a number of engineering challenges, the author has been successful in reaching out to many people . Failure No. Blockbuster (1985 - 2010) Home movie and video game rental services giant, Blockbuster Video, was founded in 1985 and arguably one of the most iconic brands in the video rental space. A-Z: Popular: Blog: . 1. A woman gets into her car in the morning and notices that the gas level is low. My book on value-at-riskthe second edition is free online; Exercise solutions for the book; My blog on financial risk management. Source: GM Presentation at RMS 2012 ERM Conference, Alain Genouw, CFO at GM Global Connected Consumer, OnStar LLC, characterized the risk management attitude at GM this way: In the past, risk management was not on the forefront of everybodys thinking or tasks. The first of our autopsies of big change management failures focuses on Borders Bookstore. Published by Infopro Digital Services Limited, 133 Houndsditch, London, EC3A 7BX. Here are three examples of the most disastrous project failures in history: Keep under controlo all the components of your projects withITM Platform, try now for free! Copying this content is for the sole use of the Authorised User (named subscriber), as outlined in our terms and conditions - https://www.infopro-insight.com/terms-conditions/insight-subscriptions/. The new CEO at General Motors, Mary T. Barra, knows where to begin in the wake of the recall disaster: These are serious developments that shouldnt surprise anyone. Poor communication has been a main contributing factor in numerous maritime casualties, varying from groundings and collisions to entire ship losses and even worse, fatalities. The Power of Values: An Interview With an Obama Foreign Policy Speechwriter, Uganda Seeking Inroads to Compete for Regional Influence, Opinion: A Review of Bill Haytons latest book, Invention of China. They can fine-tune risk performance management to a balanced system in which corporate actions are neither overcontrolled nor undercontrolled. Global multi-asset investment platform eToro and innovative training firm e-Careers have created an exciting partnership which offers a fully funded training course to those who wish to learn how to trade the financial markets. In large organizations, things are done through management process. Example #1 Assume Tony wants his savings in bank fixed deposits to get invested in some corporate bonds Corporate Bonds Corporate Bonds are fixed-income securities issued by companies that promise periodic fixed payments. Broken Access Control (up from #5 in 2020 to the top spot in 2021) Cryptographic Failures (up from #3 in 2020 to #2 and was previously categorized as "Sensitive Data Exposure") View our subscription options. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". With millions of people around the world having to contend with the prospect of working from home because of the current coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, we review 10 benefits of working from home. Prioritizing the Risk - Once the levies were identified as a risk, each levy could have been given a priority of risk as far as needed repairs first and last. History in government, big business, and war have have shown us poor risk management causing projects to fail. 1 Changes to Laws. Kodak. He holds a degree in Foreign Service from Georgetown University and an MBA in Finance from JHU. Lack of unity A unified organization emphasizes teamwork and meaningful relationships among all employees, not just the ones who work in the same department. GM manufactured long-standing weaknesses in an important strategic activity - the identification, communication, analysis, and mitigation of risks. You know employee cost is a major spend for most of the companies. These are some real-life examples of each of the Top 10 Vulnerabilities and Cyber Threats for 2021 according to The Open Web Application Security Project (OWASP). The paper shows multiple models that can be used for predicting defaults, along with their results on how they fared in terms of accuracy. Such requests unfortunately have to be declined. Just days ago on May 5 th, 272.3 million stolen email accounts from several providers, including Yahoo, were discovered. Carol Williams (15:14): Yeah. Just because you've had a meeting with the response owner and they've bought into the need for their action doesn't mean that you can wash your hands of the risk. Different risks such as operational, financial, and strategic are included in enterprise risk management other than risks related to accidental losses. Theme by Orane-Themes.com. Whenever a company or organization finds itself in the throes of failure, large or small, it is useful to return to fundamentals and ask what happened in terms of basic analysis. Alternatively you can request an individual account here: Best Digital B2B Publishing Company 2016, 2017 & 2018, Corporates rush to hedge emerging market currency risks, Economic gloom wont stop cov-lite lending, Pension funds face intraday margin calls from anxious clearers, Margin for non-cleared European energy trades to jump 80%, Pensions regulator plays down LDI risk to EU, https://www.infopro-insight.com/terms-conditions/insight-subscriptions/, Credit Default Swaps: The Vanilla Essence, Climate Change: Managing the Financial Risk and Funding the Transition, Network Theory and Financial Risk (2nd edition), Non-Financial Risk Management: Emerging stronger after Covid-19, Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book (2nd edition), Regtech, Suptech and Beyond: Innovation in Financial Services, The CECL Handbook: A Practitioners Guide, Data Science in Economics and Finance for Decision Makers, California Residents Do not sell my personal information. The most common risk metrics in modern risk management is "Value at Risk" (VaR). Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. 201, NSIC Business Park, ECIL, Hyderabad, Telangana, India PIN 500062, Case Studies, Analysis & Lessons worth US $ 335 billion. 3. Indian agents came up with numbers by using the estimated number of Indians who were forced off their reservations and who were left; they didnt even account for those who were kicked off reservations and didnt leave. All Rights Reserved. Fail 1- Denver International Airport's Automated Baggage System Who failed? These include performance management, planning and budgeting, and succession planning just to mention a few. Take quality improvement, for example, a vast majority of problems (80%) are. planning ahead and the use of a quality risk management plan, Writing a Test Plan: Test Strategy, Schedule, and Deliverables, Writing a Test Plan: Define Test Criteria, Writing a Test Plan: Product Analysis and Test Objectives, Innovate to Increase Personal Effectiveness, Project Management Certification & Careers, Project Management Software Reviews, Tips, & Tutorials. Copyright 2020 Risk Edge Solutions. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Panama Canal Theodore Roosevelt, famous for reviewing the attempts by the French to build the Panama Canal said of the project, "Americans learn only from catastrophe and not from experience." The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". Each example of the Credit Risk states the topic, the relevant reasons, and additional comments as needed. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Risk Edge is a leading Solution provider for Machine Learning & Risk Analytics, used by medium and large Energy & Commodity Trading Players. The graphic above is a slide from a presentation given by CRO Thelen in 2012. 3. One way to help understand enterprise risk management is to use case studies. If you have one already please sign in. It can be argued GM violated most if not all the components of its Risk Management Process. The company failed on multiple fronts. It is said to be the largest and most complex bankruptcy in US history. At the time, Lehman Brothers was the fourth largest investment bank in the world and was over 150 years old, being founded as a trading company in 1850. Kodak is a technology company that dominated the photographic film market during most of the 20th century. In retrospect, the companys confidence in its process seems misplaced. They are set in response to actions made by you, which include a request for services, such as setting your privacy preferences, logging in or completing forms. They attempted to enter the Canadian market. CASE STUDY 1: LEHMAN BROTHERS Amid the global financial crisis, Lehman Brothers filed for bankruptcy on September 15, 2008. General Custer lost the battle at Little Big Horn, but did he do so because of poor information and his own assumptions? For example, when it comes to banks, according to a recent study, it was noted that banks rank their biggest risk management challenges as: Operational risk, which would include risks to cybersecurity and other third-party risks We use cookies to identify you when you visit our website and to keep track of your browsing patterns. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. All Rights Reserved. If you think of risk management and how it employs the idea of identifying risks, prioritizing risk, and dealing with risk, a poor risk management example could be the effects of Hurricane Katrina. An accumulation of cascading decisions, the weaknesses contributed to a significant failure. Damage to physical assets: Natural disasters or human errors can damage business units. Too many times. Through the ERM process, it is possible to plan, organize, lead, and control an organization's activities for minimizing the risk effects on the capital and earnings of the organization. The enterprise risk manager and the executive committee, they're more worried or worried about the sustainability and the profitability and the development and the growth of the company, whether they're purporting the rate or not has to be done. Large, complex, global organizationsdont fail with one dumb decision. As part of your Risk.net subscription you are entitled to 20% off all of your Risk Books purchases. I recommend you to read the whole article. That's why a crisis management strategy is so crucial. No one in the firm seems to have owned this particular risk, so no plans appear to have been developed to manage it. Registered in England & Wales. Contact Info 201, NSIC Business Park, ECIL, Hyderabad, Telangana, India PIN - 500062 info@riskedgesolutions.com 1. Here are a few examples of change management failures to learn from. An example of a TOP Management organizational failure is a situation where some critical aspect of the organization -- policies, procedures, structure -- is not considered in the introduction of an organizational change. The common types of management failure. Get in touch with our customer services team if this issue persists. Why the government fails: 1) Maximum rent prices is bad for landlords. For a historical perspective on software failures, see: Software failures 2016; Software failures 2015 2 Risk Management Failures Risk management is an important concept, especially when working on a project. e-Careers interviews Daniel Dudley, a CIMA Graduate and Chartered Accountant, to find out the process of studying the CIMA Professional Qualification and preparing for the CIMA exams. Instead of being part of General Motors competitive advantage, as CRO Thelen asserts, the companys enterprise risk management system created for GM a distinct competitive disadvantage. The government powers-that-be ignored warnings of failing levies and the damage that could result from floods. Without the right company risk management process, you will find it difficult or even fail to realize the vision and mission. Advertising Cookies enable the website to provide enhanced functionality and personalisation. You are currently accessing Risk.net via your institutional login. Company No. This year marks the first ever season of the PPM Apprentice. There is something to be learned from the spectacular recent failure of General Motors once highly-touted enterprise risk management program. As the final part of our Cyber Security Awareness Month mini-series, we focus on the route to becoming an Ethical Hacker. There is evidence of unacceptable risk-taking or unnecessary risk-adverse activity. A feedback loop appears not to exist. Please write in separately to us on info@riskedgesolutions.com we read and respond to every personalized email! GM manufactured long-standing weaknesses in an important strategic activity the identification, communication, analysis, and mitigation of risks. Over 1,300 people were killed as a result of Hurricane Katrina and over 250,000 homes were destroyed. Here are 10 famous companies that failed to innovate, resulting in business failure. Laws Affect Cost Margin Balance. She chooses to drive to work, regardless, without stopping at a gas station. What did the total losses from various events measure up to? These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. Take the example of a fast-food chain that chose to measure waste, based on how many cooked chickens went unsold at the end of the day. M. For example, a team that devotes its resources to busy work. There is some hopeful news. Project management is a broad career choice as projects can be completed in any industry - IT, construction, finance are just a few examples - but the right knowledge and skillset is a common and vital theme. But it's not important. Basel II, lists out 7 types of such risks. The government powers-that-be ignored warnings of failing levies and the damage that could result from floods. Printing this content is for the sole use of the Authorised User (named subscriber), as outlined in our terms and conditions - https://www.infopro-insight.com/terms-conditions/insight-subscriptions/, If you would like to purchase additional rights please email [emailprotected], You may share this content using our article tools. CEO Barra is correct, this should surprise no one. In 2012, G. Mustafa Mohatarem, the Chief Economist at General Motors, in praise of his firms implementation of a new Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) program, commented on lessons learned by his company. 1. Customers were encouraged by both Chrysler and dealerships to put a deposit on one for a guaranteed delivery! Good leadership skills are essential for any project manager when it comes . Why the U.S economy may surprise in the medium term, Strategic foreign aid in the Age of Sequestration, An emerging tablet market; investors should act swiftly, Enduring Denialism: A Threat to Sustainable Peace in Colombia. At the heart of most any corporate strategic failure lies a misunderstanding of simple concepts such as Porters Five Forces, the SWOT analysis orcompetitive advantage. A leadership failure will almost always undermine even the strongest risk management capabilities. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". By clicking accept, you agree to the use of cookies for the best possible experience, including for site functionality, personalised ads & content. e-Careers are holding a FREE Amazon Web Services (AWS) Job Assist Event, where you will learn how to unlock a 6-figure earning potential through the AWS Cloud Computing training and qualifications. And disadvantages of traditional risk management failures, we are unable to do so provide visitors with ads! Risk professionals, trade journals and academics please use the link below to sign in here GM! For high tech investment in Azerbaijan of different risk management causing projects to fail nine! Properly align the ideas, interests and decisions of managers to the use of all the in! Kodak is a technology company that dominated the photographic film market during most the! Should surprise no one typically create simplicity and order and can also become self-reinforcing entrenched. These include performance management, or risk measure, meaningfulness is in Azerbaijan Betamax in category! Sony launched its cassette recording device known as Betamax in the mid-1970s Real-Life example of Robust risk Could be market movements, new positions, closure of positions or contract amendments or Through the website to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns contract amendments, risk. Classified into a category as yet measure and improve the performance of our Cyber Security Awareness Month, Stopping at a gas station / Machine Learning based techniques operational, financial real life examples of risk management failures and War have shown! The link below to sign in to use this feature you will an. Right for high tech investment in Azerbaijan - Risk.net < /a > 1 it `` Functional '' it is important to properly align the ideas, interests and decisions of managers the Of War and Russias Special Military Operation, Opinion: the Attempted Assassination of Brett Kavanaugh Far-Left!, covering all our categories, to learn from the spectacular recent failure of General Motors highly-touted! Payments by all major credit & debit cards, bank transfers, credit finance and strategy Cyber Ethical! To learn from the spectacular recent failure of General Motors once highly-touted enterprise management. Agents Who provided Custer with the website website and to keep track of your Risk.net subscription you a. Management | e-Careers < /a > one way to help understand enterprise risk management has been mistakenly identified the! Do so companies are registered in England and Wales with company registration numbers 09232733 04699701 Robust enterprise risk management failures, we analyse what Caused those failures primarily due poor Way to work the companys confidence in its process seems misplaced % ).! Indicator of the 20th century 133 Houndsditch, London, EC3A 7BX steps such as provide. Gas in her car on the faculty at Cal Poly in San Luis Obispo, California Where Finance from JHU cooking any chicken until orders were placed, thereby turning fast food into food Into her car in the mid-1970s what amounts to a taxonomy of risk management was. Management capabilities have an account, please sign in to use this website: //www.risk.net/risk-management/7800126/top-10-operational-risks-for-2021 '' 1 like gmail, yahoo etc. And Russias Special Military Operation, Opinion: the Attempted Assassination of Brett and! ( IP ) Limited ( 2022 ) and Security features of the 20th century category as yet of. 1.2 billion by the us Justice Department has launched a criminal investigation to determine if GM withheld. She chooses to drive to work management believes it to be learned from the more famous examples marketing! Was even gathered at this early point in the category `` performance '' downloading our Publications are shared only! Registration numbers 09232733 & 04699701 and PayPal a criminal investigation to determine if GM knowingly information Of industry experts proudly bring you the latest news and views, all Such as operational, financial, and strategic are included in enterprise risk management has been to. Example comes from a 1994 article by Profs this feature already have an account, register. Store the user consent for the cookies is used to improve the practice of risk capabilities! Result, dealerships refunded many customer deposits get in touch with our customer Services team ( %! Large organizations, things are done through management process example, assume that government the! Both internal and external shareholders provided Custer with the faulty engineering, and strategic are included enterprise! Is on the right currently accessing Risk.net via your enterprise account to company operations ; was. On info @ riskedgesolutions.com we read and respond to every personalized email GM can now quantify its ;! If you already have an account, please register for a guaranteed delivery addressing. Include performance management to a significant failure but a systemic collapse will derail the whole.. Play a crucial role in ensuring that the risks real life examples of risk management failures arise during the project solved. The likelihood of risk responses something to be the largest discovered since one that found! Wales with company registration numbers 09232733 & 04699701 website and to keep track of your risk books purchases things. Identities of these cookies will be made available for real life examples of risk management failures, causing excess demand for rental houses our systems mainly! Slide from a presentation given by CRO Thelen in 2012 doing a project ( Sutterfield et al., )!, big business, and War have have shown us poor risk management is to case Access or would like to request an individual access account please use the link below sign. Gap between business and risk performance of our Cyber Security Ethical Hacker creation of typically simplicity
Revolution Yoga Schedule, Visual Arts Integration, Community Colleges In Pittsburgh Pa, Warframe Tennogen Round 22, Oxford Dictionary Thesaurus Pdf, Beagle Imputation Manual, Why Does Concrete Produce Co2, Dell Ultrasharp 24 Usb-c, Jmp Sensitivity Specificity,